On the Frontlines of Reform
Creating a sustainable culture of teaching
and learning
In
the book The Diagnostic Teacher: Constructing
New Approaches to Professional Development, EDC researchers Mildred Z. Solomon and
Catherine Cobb Morocco contrast traditional models of professional
learning for teachers with standard practice in other professions:
The assumption . . .that professional development
takes place within communities of practitioners runs deep in
many professions. Whether in law, medicine, architecture, or
physics, a sense of connection to other contributing members
is at the very core of what it means to be a professional. .
. .Professionals are identified not only by their specialized
learning but also by their socialization into membership organizations
and their affiliation with colleagues who are the source of new
knowledge and lifelong learning.
In the field of education,
the concept of communities of competent professionals actively
and interactively building
on one another's knowledge of students, their disciplines,
and pedagogy is a radical departure from most current conceptions
of teaching and, consequently, of professional development.
In
the majority of schools today, "staff developers," often
with minimal classroom teacher participation, plan and provide
inservice "training." Most often, these trainings
take the form of single workshops, or sometimes a course involving
several sessions. The emphasis is on the staff developer presenting
or transmitting pedagogical strategies that teachers will apply
to their particular students and classrooms. A "deficit" model
frequently underlies this conception, with the assumption
that teachers' missing skills have been identified.
Solomon and Morocco go on to issue a call to action
for a reconception of professional education for teachers:
Tather than seeing professional development as the
transmission of knowledge and practices from staff developer
to teacher, we need to invent a new model in which staff developers
and teachers join with one another to build a common professional
community.
That sort of model of professional development is currently being
pioneered and studied in many districtsincluding several
urban districts participating in the National Science Foundation's
Urban Systemic Initiative (USI) and Urban Systemic Program (USP).
EDC researchers Brian Lord and Barbara Miller are studying teacher
leadership programs in six USI and USP sites to better understand
the contributions of fulltime teacher leaders to the professional
learning of mathematics and science teachers throughout the district.
"Standardsbased reforms call for a new depth of mathematical
understanding and ability on the part of teachers as well as students," says
Lord. He and Miller are interested in learning whether teacher
leadership programs have the potential to bring about the kind
of deep and lasting improvement in teaching and learning that the
standards movement requires. "Assessments alone won't do it.
Curriculum alone won't do it. High standards alone won't do it," says
Lord. "At some point you have to ensure that teachers are
learning what they need to know to help kids meet these tougher
requirements."
"Teacher Leadership Programs" describes the work of
teacher leaders in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and El Paso, Texas.
Another promising model of professional learning communities are
wholefaculty study groups, currently underway in many schools
participating in EDC's ATLAS
Communities program. In the ATLAS
model, study groups support a broader comprehensive reform effort
by bringing together teachers and administrators from across a
group or "pathway" of schools in a district to examine
a particular teaching and learning challenge. The sessions are
determined by student and teacher needs and interests and generally
revolve around the close examination of student work. "The
teachers in our school had been isolationist, working behind closed
doors," says Pat Sullivan, principal of Everett High, an ATLAS
school in Everett, Washington. "We really didn't know one
another professionally, even though some of us had been teaching
in classrooms right next door to each other for 20 years." "WholeFaculty
Study Groups" looks at how these groups have supported the
comprehensive reform effort in Everett, while transforming the
school's professional culture.
For questions or comments, contact mosaic@edc.org.
Copyright 2000-2003
Education Development Center, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
|